A Hindu Undivided Family (HUF) is a distinct legal entity under Hindu law, recognised for tax purposes under the Income Tax Act.

It consists of individuals descended from a common ancestor, including family members such as sons, daughters, and wives.

Traditionally, the senior most male member of the family held the role of Karta, responsible for managing the ancestral property, financial decisions, and taxation matters of the HUF.

With evolving legal interpretations and the push for equal rights, a crucial question arises: Can women be the Karta of a Hindu Undivided Family?

Legal Recognition Of Women As Karta In HUF

1. Hindu Succession Act and Women’s Rights

The Hindu Succession Act, 1956, primarily governed property rights in an HUF. However, the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, granted equal rights to female members, allowing unmarried daughters and married daughters to become equal partners in the HUF.

2. Delhi High Court Ruling on Women as Karta

In a landmark judgement, the Delhi High Court ruled that women can act as Karta of an HUF. The ruling emphasised that if a female member is the eldest coparcener, she is entitled to manage the affairs of the joint family property and perform all responsibilities associated with the role.

3. Can a Widow Be a Karta?

Following the Delhi High Court ruling, a widow or the next eldest female member can take charge of the HUF in the absence of a senior male member. This judgment reinforced that Hindu law must be interpreted in a manner that grants equal rights to female members.

Taxation & Financial Implications Of A Female Karta

1. HUF as a Separate Taxable Entity

Under income tax laws, an HUF is considered a separate taxable entity, distinct from the personal income of its members.

The Income Tax Department allows HUFs to file income tax returns separately, offering various tax benefits to its members.

2. Income Tax Benefits and Deductions for HUF

A HUF's income is taxed separately, and the following tax benefits can be claimed:

• Tax deductions under Section 80C for home loan repayments, insurance premiums, and investments.
• Deduction on interest paid on a self-occupied property.
• Education cess and salary expense deductions if the HUF pays salaries to its members for managing the family business.
• Income from joint family property is taxed separately from the personal income of the Karta.

3. How Women Karta Can Claim Tax Deductions?

A female Karta can legally manage the bank account of an HUF and file income tax returns under the HUF's Permanent Account Number (PAN).

She can also:

• Claim tax deductions under Section 80C, 80D, and 80G.
• Utilise home loan repayment benefits.
• Avail exemptions on income from ancestral property.

4. Old Tax Regime vs New Tax Regime for HUF

The new tax regime introduced by the Income Tax Act gives HUFs the option to choose between the old tax regime (which allows tax deductions) and the new tax regime (which has lower tax rates but does not allow certain deductions).

The Karta, whether male or female, is responsible for selecting the best tax-saving approach for the HUF.

Challenges Faced By Women As Karta

1. Resistance from Family Members

Despite the legal recognition, some HUF members may challenge the authority of a female Karta based on traditional beliefs.

2. Practical Issues in Property Management

Managing ancestral property and filing income tax returns for an HUF requires financial expertise, which some female members may not have had the opportunity to develop.

3. Registration and Compliance Issues

For a woman to officially become a Karta, the HUF must be formally registered, and proper documentation, such as a legal deed, is required.

The Bottom Line

With the legal recognition of women as Karta, the traditional structure of an Hindu Undivided Family (HUF) has evolved.

Women can now not only inherit but also manage family wealth, ensuring the continuation of the HUF structure while leveraging income tax benefits.

The decision to appoint a female Karta should be based on capability rather than gender, aligning with modern legal interpretations and the changing dynamics of Hindu family structures.

‍