A Gift Deed is a legal document that facilitates the voluntary transfer of property ownership from one person (donor) to another (donee) without any monetary consideration.

Governed by the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, a gift deed must comply with legal procedures, including Gift Deed registration at the sub registrar's office and payment of applicable stamp duty.

While a registered Gift Deed is generally legally binding, there are circumstances where a Deed Gift can be challenged in court.

Understanding the legal framework, potential disputes, and loopholes can help property owners avoid complications.

Can A Gift Deed Be Challenged?

Yes, a Gift Deed can be challenged under specific circumstances. Although a registered Gift Deed is presumed legally valid, the donee or other family members may contest it if:

• The donor was coerced or influenced.
• The Gift Deed was not executed properly.
• The donor lacked mental capacity.
• There was fraud or misrepresentation.
• The property ownership had existing disputes.

Legal Loopholes To Avoid When Creating A Gift Deed

1. Ensuring Free Consent

One of the primary reasons a Gift Deed is challenged is undue influence, coercion, or fraud. The donor and the donee must voluntarily enter into the agreement.

To avoid disputes:

• The donor should sign the Gift Deed in the presence of two Witnesses.
• The document should include a detailed description of the property details and the intention behind the voluntary transfer.
• Proof of sound mind and free will should be established.

2. Proper Gift Deed Registration

As per the Property Act, 1882, a Gift Deed must be registered at the sub registrar's office to be legally binding. Failing to do so can make the deed invalid.

The registration process includes:

• Submitting identity proofs (such as PAN card, Aadhaar card, and address proof).
• Payment of Gift Deed registration charges and stamp duty.
• Ensuring property ownership is clear and free from legal disputes.
• Obtaining an encumbrance certificate to verify that the property has no outstanding liabilities.

3. Stamp Duty Compliance

The donor and donee must ensure that the stamp duty payment is made as per state laws, as stamp duty varies across India. Without proper stamp duty, the Gift Deed can be rendered invalid.

4. Clear Property Title and Ownership

A Gift Deed must only be executed by the lawful owner of the property. Before transferring property, ensure:

• The title deed is in the donor's name.
• The property ownership has no disputes.
• The property is free from encumbrances.

5. Understanding Tax Implications

Under the Income Tax Act, gift property received from non-relatives may be subject to tax exemptions and tax implications. Some key points:

• Gifts from family members (parents, spouse, children) are tax-free.
• Gifts above ₹50,000 from non-relatives may be taxable.
• Agricultural land, growing crops, and standing timber may have different tax considerations.

6. Legal Challenges Based on Revocation Clauses

A Gift Deed must clearly state whether it is revocable or irrevocable. If the donor includes a revocation clause, the donee agrees that the gift can be withdrawn under certain conditions.

Common Grounds For Challenging A Gift Deed

1. Fraud or Misrepresentation

If the donee obtained the property through fraudulent means, the Gift Deed can be legally challenged.

2. Lack of Mental Capacity

If the donor was not in good health or had diminished mental capacity at the time of execution, the deed can be disputed.

3. Improper Execution

A Gift Deed requires:

• Proper documentation of property details.
• Execution in the presence of at least two Witnesses.
• Registration at the sub registrar's office.

Failure to meet these requirements can result in the Gift Deed being void.

4. Challenge by Legal Heirs

If a Gift Deed unfairly deprives legal heirs, they may contest it, especially if it contradicts succession laws.

How To Protect A Gift Deed From Legal Challenges

To ensure the Gift Deed is legally valid and withstands potential legal disputes, follow these precautions:

• Clearly state intentions: The donor must explicitly mention the reason for gifting property.
• Use a well-drafted Gift Deed format: Ensure all essential key components are included.
• Register separately: In case of joint ownership, the Gift Deed must be executed individually by each owner.
• Attach necessary documents: Submit all required documents, including address proof, PAN card, title deed, and identity proofs.
• Ensure presence of two Witnesses: This helps prevent allegations of coercion or fraud.
• Avoid conditional gifting: If a Gift Deed includes multiple conditions, it increases the chances of legal disputes.

The Bottom Line: How Yellow Can Help

While a Gift Deed is a legally binding document that facilitates property transfers, it is still subject to legal disputes under specific circumstances.

Ensuring proper Gift Deed registration, meeting legal requirements, and avoiding legal loopholes can help in protecting the donor and the donee from future complications.

By following best practices and ensuring all necessary precautions, one can transfer property smoothly and secure ownership without legal hurdles.

At Yellow, we can help you with all aspects of estate planning, including Wills, Trusts, Powers of Attorney, Gift Deeds, Legal Heir and Succession Certificates, and Living Wills. We also offer post-demise and asset transfer services. Our team of legal experts has more than 50 years of combined experience.

‍